Search Our Agents & Offices
Let us help you find an agent or office near you.
Holly Carter
REALTOR, Broker / Owner
REALTOR, ABR
License Number: 57527
Holly Carter brings a wealth of experience and passion to the real estate industry, having served as a dedicated Realtor since 2012. Her career took a significant turn in January 2018 when she played a pivotal role in launching NextHome Priority, a decision that underscored her commitment to enhancing the real estate landscape. NextHome Priority is locally owned and operated, allows Holly and her team to contribute directly to the growth and prosperity of Central Wisconsin, prioritizing local organizations and individuals in their endeavors.
Holly’s academic background, a Bachelor’s degree in Business Management from the University of Phoenix obtained in 2007, laid the foundation for her successful career. However, it is her deep-seated passion for community involvement and volunteering that truly defines her. Currently, Holly serves as an Ambassador for the Portage County Business Council and holds a position on the Portage County Housing Authority Board of Directors, roles that allow her to give back to the community she so dearly cherishes.
Why choose Holly Carter as your Realtor? Holly’s genuine joy in facilitating the home buying and selling process is evident. The highlight of her job is the moment she can share the exhilarating news of an accepted offer with her clients, a testament to her client-focused approach. Holly’s enthusiasm for her work and her clients’ happiness is a driving force in her career.
Holly’s exceptional performance is evident in her inclusion in the prestigious Masters Club for three consecutive years, 2021, 2022, and 2023, during which she helped close to 40 families each year find or sell their homes. This achievement is not just a reflection of her professional competence but also her dedication to making a difference in people’s lives through real estate.
Looking forward to the future, Holly Carter is eager to continue making dreams come true for more families and individuals. With a track record of success, a heart for her community, and a love for the work she does, Holly is not just a Realtor; she’s a trusted partner in your real estate journey.
20 Park Ridge Drive, Stevens Point, WI 54481
Coverage
Amherst, Custer, Mosinee, Plover, Rosholt, Stevens Point and Wausau
Awards
2018 Masters Club Award Winner, 2018 Pinnacle Office Award Winner, 2019 Pinnacle Office Award Winner, 2020 Pinnacle Office Award Winner, 2021 Diamond Pinnacle Office Award Winner, 2021 Masters Club Award Winner, 2022 Diamond Pinnacle Office Award Winner, 2022 Masters Club Award Winner, 2023 Diamond Pinnacle Office Award Winner and 2023 Masters Club Associate Award Winner
Recommendations
Holly went above and beyond to exceed my expectations!
Working with Holly was an absolute pleasure from start to finish. I recently sold my condo and purchased a new home. As a third-time homebuyer, she provided valuable insight into the local market and trends. I was most impressed with her communication and personal approach. She kept me informed at every stage and promptly answered all my questions. She listened to my needs and delivered exceptional results. I couldn’t be happier with my new home and highly recommend Holly to anyone looking for a knowledgeable and supportive agent.
Working with Holly was an absolute pleasure from start to finish. I recently sold my condo and purchased a new home. As a third-time homebuyer, she provided valuable insight into the local market and trends. I was most impressed with her communication and personal approach. She kept me informed at every stage and promptly answered all my questions. She listened to my needs and delivered exceptional results. I couldn’t be happier with my new home and highly recommend Holly to anyone looking for a knowledgeable and supportive agent.
As a first time homebuyer, Holly helped me navigate through the process worry-free. Holly is very communicative, attentive, friendly, and someone who is committed to helping you find a house you love. With Holly in my corner, I closed on my first home
within a month after our offer was accepted, and I couldn't be happier!
Working with Holly was a truly positive experience. She handled a complicated divorce situation with professionalism and compassion, making a potentially stressful process feel surprisingly easy. Thanks to her clear communication, expert guidance, and
lightning-fast responsiveness, selling my home felt seamless from start to finish.
I needed to sell my father's property in Wisconsin and I live out of state. Holly was there for us every step of the way, even providing resources for decluttering and removal of personal property. She is, without a doubt, a top professional in her field
and I highly recommend her services.
Holly was recommended to me by my mom as my realtor for purchasing my first house. She did an excellent job in helping me along with the process and giving me advice along the way, along with helping with closing. I will certainly be recommending her to
anyone in the area that needs a realtor!
Holly Carter with Next Home Priority was highly recommended by family for a recent home purchase in Central Wisconsin. She was extremely responsive, attentive and listened to my wishes. Her professionalism, local knowledge and expertise made the entire
process, from the initial search, to viewings and completion, both straightforward and timely, leading to a move within 7 weeks. I would highly recommend Holly to anyone searching for a new home/property in Wisconsin. I could not be happier with her assistance
making the purchase process go smoothly. Thank you Holly!
I gladly recommend Holly as an exceptional realtor. As a second-time homebuyer, we were fortunate to have her guiding us through the process. When we found a property on short notice, Holly was quick to arrange showings not just once, but twice over the
weekend. Her dedication and responsiveness made all the difference, helping us fall in love with what would become our dream home.
Throughout the negotiation process, Holly was invaluable. She provided keen insights into what other buyers were doing, helping us craft a competitive offer that was ultimately accepted. Her support didn’t stop there; she consistently checked in with us, answered our questions, and kept us updated on the progress of our purchase. Holly ensured that the closing process was seamless, making a potentially stressful experience feel manageable. Our family of four couldn’t be happier in our new home, and we wholeheartedly recommend Holly to anyone looking to find their perfect place.
Throughout the negotiation process, Holly was invaluable. She provided keen insights into what other buyers were doing, helping us craft a competitive offer that was ultimately accepted. Her support didn’t stop there; she consistently checked in with us, answered our questions, and kept us updated on the progress of our purchase. Holly ensured that the closing process was seamless, making a potentially stressful experience feel manageable. Our family of four couldn’t be happier in our new home, and we wholeheartedly recommend Holly to anyone looking to find their perfect place.
Holly was outstanding. From the first day putting the home on the market she was always there to answer any questions. Sold the house in 24 hours after putting it on the market. When it came to the closing, she answered all my questions and was there every
step of the way.
Would highly recommend her, if you are selling or buying.
Would highly recommend her, if you are selling or buying.
Very knowledgeable and extremely helpful when going through the home buying process especially as a first time home buyer
Holly was great and knowledgeable. Holly was available almost 24/7 which was great for last minute worries or questions. Holly did very thorough walkthroughs of all the houses that I wanted to see and pointed out things I should be worried about etc. Couldn't
have been better!
Holly worked tirelessly from beginning to end of my home purchase.
I highly recommend her if you’re serious about purchasing a home.
I highly recommend her if you’re serious about purchasing a home.
Holly was great to work with. She was our eyes and ears since we lived 9 hours away and was able to do virtual tours with us online. She made it possible for our family to get an offer in on our dream home which was accepted! She also gave us a great loan
officer recommendation which made the loan process so easy! Would highly recommend Holly 10 out of 10!
Holly was amazing from start to finish! As first-time home buyers, we were not knowledgeable about the process of buying a home. She walked us through everything - answered all of our questions and was available for what seemed like 24-7. She was thorough
in walking through the houses with us and giving her opinion when asked - but letting us do the major decision making. This made us very comfortable, and we felt very much in control of our purchase - meaning she was not pushy at all!!!
When the offer on our home was accepted, she contacted us late at night to let us know as we were very patiently waiting to hear. She celebrated with us and was as excited as we were when everything went through. I cannot say enough good things about Holly and recommend working with her if you are in the search for a home or selling your home. Holly is the absolute best!!
When the offer on our home was accepted, she contacted us late at night to let us know as we were very patiently waiting to hear. She celebrated with us and was as excited as we were when everything went through. I cannot say enough good things about Holly and recommend working with her if you are in the search for a home or selling your home. Holly is the absolute best!!
Holly was a pleasure to work with! She kept us informed, offered great advice, was willing to stop by the property at any time and provided a personal touch that made the experience stress-free!
Holly was terrific! I was looking to downsize and she made searching realistic and practical. She listened to me and didn't waste my time looking at places that didn't meet my needs. I love my new home and would highly recommend her to anyone who wants
personal attention to details.
Holly was great to work with and made our first time home buying experience easy and straightforward. She was professional, knowledgeable, and responsive; helping us to quickly find the perfect home while moving in from out of town. I highly recommend
Holly for a smooth and enjoyable home-buying experience!
Holly was spectacular to have throughout our home buying process. She’s extremely knowledgeable and was very communicative and responsive. She made the entire process easy and enjoyable. We would recommend her to anyone we know and would work with her
again in the future.
Holly helped us through this crazy market to find our new bigger home! So thankful for her knowledge and assistance!
Holly worked with us for awhile helping us find a house. She was always quick to respond to questions and was available what felt like 24/7. I highly recommend her.
Talk about above and beyond! When I do I mention Holly’s name. She did an amazing job, when I was ready to give up she persevered. I would recommend her to anyone.
Holly was great! Super helpful, quick to respond and overall was awesome throughout the whole process!
Our first time working with Holly and it was a fantastic experience. We contacted her on a Saturday, she showed the property to us on a Sunday and by Monday we submitted an offer which was accepted on Tuesday. She was always available to answer questions
and was always one step ahead of the game. Everything went according to plan and we couldn’t be happier. We would recommend Holly to anyone. We will definitely utilize her services in the future.
Holly was an absolute joy to work with, she was always available and responsive, her knowledge was the greatest asset for us as new homebuyers it allowed everything to go super smoothly.
Holly was a great relator and I love the house I just bought!
Holly did a fantastic job for us. We were quite specific on the area we wanted to live in, and we were not pressured to look at other houses in other areas. When we did find the house we liked, and we put an offer on it, Holly helped us every step of the
way. She followed up with emails asking if we had any questions and made sure we understood everything. I would recommend Holly to anyone buying or selling a house.
Holly was wonderful to work with. We met with her 2 years ago when we were visiting the area from Hawaii in preparation to move to WI. Holly stayed in touch with us while we were in Hawaii getting ready for the big move. She was so easy to work with, even
late at night, as we got closer to closing. She made the process of buying our new home wonderful.
Great experience, easy to work with, very knowledgeable…..yay we have a home ??
Mahaloz Kevin and Ramona
Mahaloz Kevin and Ramona
Holly came highly recommended by some friends/neighbors of Mom so we were pleased to work with her. She got Mom’s house listed, organized and cleared unwanted items, held a successful estate sale, and got the house ready for sale. She brought us multiple
offers within 3 weeks of our first meeting!
Holly took the time to communicate during the whole process, was always available to talk, and made this project so much easier for us. I would highly recommend Holly, she’s awesome!
Holly took the time to communicate during the whole process, was always available to talk, and made this project so much easier for us. I would highly recommend Holly, she’s awesome!
Holly was amazing to work with! She helped me through the entire process from start to finish and made it as stress-free as possible. She did an amazing job!
She goes out of her way to ensure the house is ready for sale! If I were to sell multiple houses a year I would use Holly for everyone. Definitely gives you peace of mind knowing everything is taken cared for. 10/10 rating.
Holly was awesome to work with! It was definitely a challenge finding a house in the hot market, but Holly definitely made my first home purchase a breeze!
We enjoyed working with Holly, she was very professional, listened to what we wanted and helped us find the perfect house. She explained everything during each step of the process. We highly recommend her for your house hunting needs.
Holly is a very responsible and professional realtor. We are difficult to find a house in the hot market. Holly is very patient to company us to show different houses and talk through the house detail. We believe her so much for finding our house. Now
it becomes true. Thank you, Holly!
This is our second time working with Holly and it was another great experience! Holly always goes above and beyond to make sure we are happy! We had a very tight schedule to go and see houses and Holly made it possible to go and see as many as we could
each week! We will continue to recommend her and chose to work with her in the future as well!
Holly did wonderful in the selling of my dads house this spring. She was very easy to work with and listened to my needs along with lots of suggestions on what to have done prior to selling to get the most out of the sale. Holly was always available if
I had questions and very easy to work with. She sold my dads rentals before he passed away. My dad checked several different realtors prior to signing up with Holly, and she was the only realtor that came out to his house and sat down with him to explain and
answer questions. All the others only did phone consults. That was a big deal to my dad who was in sales all his life. Holly really likes to be in person and take time to make sure you understand and are happy. That is why I trust and work with her. Thank
you Holly ! You did great ! Brad
Holly was so helpful in getting me in my new place. I would recommend her to anyone.
Holly was fantastic throughout the buying process. We purchased our house while living in Phoenix, AZ. She is very knowledgeable and quick to respond. I would highly recommend her and her team.
Holly did a great job helping us sell our parents home. She helped us every step of the way, even when we had some hoops to jump through. I would recommend her to anyone! Thank you Holly!
Holly was phenomenal! She answered all my questions and moved the process along at the pace we needed. I highly recommend Holly!
Selling my first house was a great experience thanks to Holly. She was very helpful in explaining the whole process. I really appreciated the wonderful pictures for the listing!
The sales process was easy, prompt and fast, with over 40 showings over a weekend. Holly provided great counsel and advice, including pricing and offer negotiation. She was efficient and organized - We don’t know how it could have been easier.
Holly is the best realtor around! She was always available, extremely knowledgable, and gave us tons of helpful tips and tricks to buying a house, moving in, remodeling, etc. Our home buying experience was exciting - not stressful - all thanks to Holly.
Holly was absolutely great to work with on purchasing our beautiful new home. She was always responsive to our needs and provided honest answers to our questions. I would highly recommend Holly from NextHome.
Holly did a great Job! We are excited about our new home. We were very specific about what we did and didn't want and she listened. She delivered too. Everything was what we asked for. She was on all the details and got the paperwork done very easily.
We would highly recommend Holly for her professional and personal experience.
I would highly recommend Holly for any real estate needs. She is knowledgeable, professional and quick to respond with any questions. She made the stressful situation much easier to deal with.
Holly did a great job taking over for my current agent who had left the organization. She did an impeccable job of keeping in continual communication with me. Always staying very positive, and keeping the stress of home selling and buying to a bare minimum!
If you're in search of a real estate agent, look no further, Holly Carter is the best in the area!
She is great and easy to work with! She took us on really fast and worked with us when we had 1 day to look at all the houses on the list!
Holly was an exceptional realtor and if I had to buy or sell a house, then I would definitely hire Holly.
She provided timely and relevant insight, fully explained various options to consider, and answered all of my questions.
The process from selecting her as my relator to closing was seamless and I had no qualms and "hiccups."
Holly was always responsive and, frequently, intuited that I had questions that I failed to ask or that I forgot to ask. She was proactive in a very good way.
She is the consummate professional!
I strongly recommend hiring Holly if you want to buy or sell a house!
She provided timely and relevant insight, fully explained various options to consider, and answered all of my questions.
The process from selecting her as my relator to closing was seamless and I had no qualms and "hiccups."
Holly was always responsive and, frequently, intuited that I had questions that I failed to ask or that I forgot to ask. She was proactive in a very good way.
She is the consummate professional!
I strongly recommend hiring Holly if you want to buy or sell a house!
Holly worked hard showing us many properties and putting in offers on two other places until we found the perfect home to meet our family needs. Interested members of our family live in three different states. Holly accommodated us by setting up Zoom showings.
We would recommend using Holly to find your dream home!
Holly made a stressful situation a breeze during a pandemic. She was ready for any questions I had whether it was by a phone call, text, or email. She was very compassionate to my situation and had my best interest in mind the whole process. I will definitely
recommend her to anyone interested in buying/selling a house.
Holly was very easy to work with and great about answering questions I had as a first time home buyer. Very flexible!
Holly helped me find my first residential investment property. She was very professional, experienced and comfortable to work with. Shortly after I expressed my interest in finding an investment property to her, Holly was working hard to find me a property
that would cash flow and be a solid investment. Her candor and experience in investment properties has reassured me that I made a solid decision to purchase!
Holly was very easy to work with and answered my calls and texts promptly whenever I had a question or concern.
Holly Carter is the most amazing realtor ever! My husband and I were looking for a home in Wausau, WI, while being located in Stevens Point, WI. Holly made numerous trips to Wausau to show us various houses in the dead of winter, which we are both incredibly
thankful for. My husband and I are both under 30 years old and, as a younger couple, we were very unsure and lacking confidence in what to look for in a home; Holly was there for us to answer questions and offer advice throughout the entire process. She made
me feel so comfortable and I hadn’t imagined buying a home could be so stress-free! We got our dream home, and I know we wouldn’t have been able to do that without someone as amazing as Holly by our sides throughout this process. If and when we are ready to
look for a new home, we will definitely be turning to Holly Carter!
Holly sold my vacant residential property in the Mosinee/Wausau area. She made the process very easy and virtually stress free.
Holly is a great negotiater, so personable and kind. She always found time for me and my many questions. Thanks Holly !
Holly is a great negotiater, so personable and kind. She always found time for me and my many questions. Thanks Holly !
Holly did a great job with helping me navigate the sale of my home. I'd had a less than ideal experience with a different realtor when I purchased the house, so I was nervous and didn't quite understand the process, but she was patient and talked me through
all of it, making sure I was comfortable each step of the way. I would definitely recommend her to anybody who's buying or selling a home.
I am extremely pleased with the way Holly Carter handled the listing and sale of my house. She had 6 offers for the house in only 3 days! Couldn't ask for better results than that! I would advise anyone who is considering selling, or buying, a home to
contact Holly. She, and her staff, are top notch!
Holly was wonderful to work with and we are so happy in our new home!
Holly was AMAZING!!! I’m a first time home buyer and I had no idea where to start. Then I met holly, she made the process so easy, and as stress free as it could be. Granted buying a home is already stressful 😉. I would simply tell her which houses I
liked, we would view them on a day that was most convenient for me, she would give me advice and guide me through every aspect of what to look for in a home, if there were things that needed updating or fixing. She even had someone on site and off site that
could help me with my financing needs. I HIGHLY recommend using holly or anyone from NextHome for all of your house buying needs!
Holly was great. Explained the whole process so we understood it. Gave us advice when we put in our first offer which got accepted right away. I would highly recommend Holly to anyone looking at buying a house.
Holly was great with us as first time homebuyers. She explained everything very well so we understood the process. She gave great advice for us when we found the house we wanted. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking at buying a house.
Holly was patient with us as we moved through the home selling & home buying process. At times it felt like a roller coaster for us and Holly was there to steady “our crazy”. She was very knowledgeable about all aspects of this process and at times she
even worked some magic! We would recommend using her as your realtor if you are looking for a professional straight shooter that is willing to go the extra mile for you.
Holly was super helpful from the first phone call until the day we moved into our new home! She was so fast to reply to any/all questions, and did a great job explaining terms and things that we did not understand. I felt like I was Holly's only client
(even though I knew she has tons!) because she gave us such constant attention.
If you want to buy (or sell) a home and want it done professionally, quickly, and with everything handled for you- contact Holly Carter!
If you want to buy (or sell) a home and want it done professionally, quickly, and with everything handled for you- contact Holly Carter!
I'm so glad I was able to work with Holly on my house hunt! Being a first time home buyer Holly was able to offer me a lot of support and I never felt like I was asking dumb questions or was too in over my head. The whole home buying experience had some
ups and downs, but it all worked out in the end and Holly was there every step of the way offering me support and suggestions on next steps I was able to take. She is an extremely hard worker and was always available to help me with any questions day or night.
I highly recommend Holly and NextHome Priority!
Five stars doesn't do justice. Holly listened and kept us informed as homes came onto the market. Thanks, Holly!
Sue & Scott
Sue & Scott
Holly was fantastic. She was kind, personable, and helpful above and beyond the call. Hands down the best realtor I've worked with. You can't go wrong with her!
Holly did a great job selling our house. She was dedicated to get people in to see it by holding multiple open houses and advertising in multiple areas. Using her knowledge, we were able to sell for a great price. We really appreciate everything she did
during this process.
Holly was not only incredibly understanding of our needs vs wants, she was patient. We never felt forced or pushed into a sale. She made my husband and I super comfortable with all of her knowledge as well. Not to mention, helped us with all of our amendments
on our offers. Highly, highly recommend working with Holly. We couldn't be happier!
Holly is fantastic to work with. She is knowledgeable and professional, yet is very approachable and personally concerned about the needs and circumstances of her clients. Holly is also intuitive, pointing out things during home showings that a buyer might
not think to notice. Overall, Holly made our family's house buying experience very easy.
Holly is a very dedicated and professional agent who puts the interests of her clients first. I would highly recommend Holly for anyone looking to buy or sell a home.
As a first time home buyer Holly really made the entire process so easy.
She offered guidance and options and I really can't imagine doing it without her.
She offered guidance and options and I really can't imagine doing it without her.
Holly helped me purchase my first home. She was extremely flexible and helpful when it came to questions. She was able to answer anything I thought of and if she didn't know the answer right away she found it out and got back to me promptly. She was very
educated on the home buying process and was able to walk me through everything as it happened.
Holly was very accommodating, and very persistent with a hard lender and hard seller. She handled many issues without being asked, and kept the buyers informed.
She was wonderful! She made them selling and buying experience great! Very helpful! She listened! She wanted us to have the house that would fit our family!
Holly was very professional in her help selling and buying our houses. She made the process very smooth and was always on top of any situations that arose. After all was said and done we now consider Holly a friend. Excellent job Holly!
Holly is very personable and knowledgeable. She was able to use her contacts and insight to sell the house very quickly.
It all started when me and my fiance wanted to buy a house. We were told Next Home Priority is a great company. So we looked into it and found Holly. We got to each other more and more with each house we looked at. If I had to describe her, shes nothing
short than a miracle. We were about to give up house hunting for awail because we couldn't find a house we loved. Until Holly sent us a link to a house. We agreed to check it out and we loved it. I'd recommend Holly in a heart beat.
Holly worked with me for months on end finding a place for me and my dog, within every possible combination of options I could think of. She was dedicated and always willing to work with me to scheduling shows and answer any questions as a first time home
buyer. I couldn't recommend her anymore for someone looking for a home.
Holly made the process of buying and selling our house very easy! She was readily available to answer any questions and was very easy to work with!
Holly was AWESOME! She was never pushy, she gave amazing opinions, and she helped us through many houses and awesome recommendations! She helped make the process very fast and simple! I'd recommend Holly to anyone!
Holly did a great job finding us our first investment property. She was able to meet all of our demands and her communication is fantastic. She went above and beyond our expectations and we look forward to finding more investment properties with her as
our agent in the future.
Holly did an excellent job listing my mothers house. She was available all off the time, had answers to our questions and walked us through the selling process.
The day that the house went on the market, she had 3 interested parties walking through. 2 the next day and an open house the 3 day. Be the end of the weekend, we had 2 potential buyers.
I would recommend Holly to a friend who was looking to buy or sell a house.
The day that the house went on the market, she had 3 interested parties walking through. 2 the next day and an open house the 3 day. Be the end of the weekend, we had 2 potential buyers.
I would recommend Holly to a friend who was looking to buy or sell a house.