Search Our Agents & Offices

We have worked with Tonya on several occasions including both selling our homes and purchasing homes. She has always done a great job in a very professional manner. Her personality and dedication makes her a fabulous person to work with.

We have worked with Tonya over the last ten years on multiple buying & selling homes. She always did a great job for us. Very professional & got the job done quickly. I would highly recommend her if you are in the market to sell your home, She won’t disappoint.

Tanya is very proactive and professional and got the job done in a decent amount of time

Tonya McCarthy is amazing! She researches everything, makes calls, follow ups. She is prepared at all times to connect you with any reference point you may need. She is top of the line service and walks through the entire process with you. With Tonya, you always feel like you are her only customer- yet she had three closings and her own challenge the same time I made an offer through closing. She is highly recommended!

Tonya is an awesome realtor. She takes care of business when it comes to her buyers. She was able to guide me into closing on my dream home. Tonya, thank you for your care and guidance throughout the whole buying process, it allowed me to worry less and trust the process.
Thanks again!

I enjoyed working with Tonya McCarthy and the agency she works with. I would do it all over again. I thank you Tonya

Tonya was everything we needed and more. Buying and selling a house can be stressful enough, we were also pregnant with our first baby! We are so grateful for how seamless Tonya made the process for us and we cannot recommend her enough!

I am a first time home owner! I wasn’t sure how to handle the process of home ownership. While working with Tonya McCarthy, it was a lot of many things I didn’t know about but she was always very helpful. Tonya and I would text throughout the day. She gave me her ideas, opinions and experience on what I should do or not do. I was able to make my own decisions. We scheduled to see homes together and I would see them at the appointed time. It was a pleasure working with Tonya McCarthy, I would recommend her to others

Tonya was helpful from beginning to end with our process of moving to Avon Indiana and buying a home. She was always available to answer my numerous concerns and questions. She brought much appreciated positivity, knowledge and professionalism to the process. I highly recommend her and would call on her again for house selling/buying.

The best realtor this side of the Mississippi River!
We are so blessed to have Tonya as our realtor and a great friend!!!

Good morning ,to whom it may concern Tanya is a great person as well Realtor.I, Albert went through 2 realtors with not too much navigation but when i met Tanya i seem to hit the ground running and with the situation going in my favor , my luck securing a home went well and i cant stop thanking her. In my mind she deserves Realtor of the year and when i am approached about a home her name instantly pops in my head. Thanks thanks Tanya

Tonya was fantastic to work with. Very fast and clear with communication. So helpful in answering all of our questions. Recommend working with her, can't recommend highly enough.

Really appreciate Tonya's ability to communicate with us promptly and regularly to help us purchase a dream home. We walked in without any pre-approvals and within a couple of hours we were on our way to making an accepted offer. She helped us each step of the way and was incredibly flexible and professional with timelines. Really appreciate all her work; I would recommend her to anyone

Tonya was attentive and engaged throughout the home buying process. She was always concerned with our best interest and went out of her way to make our closing as seamless as possible. She even arranged for lawncare at our new house to ensure we arrived to freshly cut grass! Tonya is so easy to work with and I would recommend her to anyone looking for a realtor who truly works to understand her clients as much as she does the market. Thank you, Tonya!

Tonya is one of a kind! You will not find a realtor who cares more about her clients, who is willing to support them and help them and look out for their best interest more than Tonya! Her years of experience are evident in the advice that she gave us throughout the whole process. her wise words helped us navigate such a stressful process with confidence.

Tonya was absolutely wonderful to work with! She went above and beyond in helping us reach the closing table. She was knowledgeable and represented my wife and I so well. If any one is moving to the greater Indianapolis area there is no one I would recommend except Tonya!

Thank you!

Tonya does a great job providing a smooth experience. Would recommend her to anyone in the market to buy or sell.

Tonya was amazing from start to finish! She was professional, friendly, very inviting, knew her stuff and all the details that went with it. I highly recommend Tonya for showing a home, supporting your wants and needs in what you're looking for in a home.

Kudos to Tonya from start to finish once again in all your endeavors towards making us feel that you were working solely for us. This is indeed your ministry and helping people find their new home! Take care and God bless you in your real estate business! Respectfully, Darlene and Bill Schultz

Tonya was amazing!! I would highly recommend her to anyone who is buying a house. She was on top of everything and helped me find a great home. Very responsive, kind, and a joy to work with throughout the whole process. I cannot thank her enough for all her help in finding my home! :)

Tonya is the best! She is very caring and listening to what you want and caters to you and works extremely hard on your behalf. She is on top of everything and doesn’t miss any details and leads and guides you through the whole process. You couldn’t ask for a better realtor!

Tonya was very helpful in the process of me purchasing my first home. She answered all of my questions and was readily available to assist with any of my concerns. She was a true gem.

Tonya was SO helpful and knowledgeable about the market which I needed moving from another State. She was always accommodating to my schedule and we looked too many houses to count before I finally count “The One”. I highly recommend Tonya!!! She is friendly and truly cares about helping you. I loved working with her and when I buy my next house she will definitely be my first call!

Tonya is simply amazing! She is hands down the best realtor my family and I have ever worked with and we give her 5 stars in all aspects of her work. She is extremely helpful and consistently goes above and beyond for her clients, all hours of the day or night. I wish I had more space to list all the amazing things she did for our family. If you don't pick Tonya for your home buying/selling needs you're missing out!

Tonya is an excellent buyers agent who gives fantastic advice. She was calm and helpful throughout our entire home buying process- even during the most stressful moments.

She's genuinely caring and willing to go the extra mile for her clients. We just closed on our house two weeks ago and have to already recommended her to several friends.

Tonya did a great job helping my wife and I connect with a great home that suited our needs and fit within our budget - all in a tough market for buyers! She was very helpful throughout the whole process. You won't regret choosing Tonya to help you find your next home!

We were so blessed to have Tonya as our agent. From day one she showed the perfect balance of professionalism and warmth. Her expertise and wide range of knowledge was very helpful and made for a trouble-free escrow even though we were new to Indiana.

Tonya was just great to work with. Knowledgeable & effective in business dealings. Warm & caring on a personal level. Very important when you’re dealing in high-stakes home sales. Highly Recommend !

Truly an absolute joy to work with, she was very quick in getting me set up with a mortgage lender and pre approval (within hours) and got me in with a competitive offer.

Highly recommend!

Tonya,
Is an amazing caring kind and giving of her time excellent realtor. She is committed to finding you the home that’ll best suit your needs and wants. Tonya walks with you through the whole entire process going above and beyond the call of duty I could not recommend a better realtor.

Tonya , is an excellent realtor. She takes excellent care of you helping you find your right home. This time she helped me sell my home in one day. From staging to closing Tonya has always been there and does an excellent job for her clients.

Tonya was an amazing realtor. Not only was she very professional she was very caring and always listened to our concerns. She went above and beyond realtor duties to help us get exactly what we wanted.

I would recommend Tonya to anyone who is looking for a new home. You will not be disappointed in her from a professional, or personal standpoint!

Tonya did such a great job helping me with getting through the process of purchasing a home where I wanted and when I wanted she was fast and very professional thank you Tonya your the best and you will be my future realtor but I’ll probably never move that’s how happy I am…

Tonya did such a great job helping me with getting through the process of purchasing a home where I wanted and when I wanted she was fast and very professional thank you Tonya your the best and you will be my future realtor but I’ll probably never move that’s how happy I am…

My fiancée Sydney and I could not imagine going through this process with a better realtor. She is caring, responsive, and always looking out for your best interest. She not only made time to show us many homes, but brought the numbers, made long drives, and wasn’t afraid to be honest with us. Home buying is stressful but Tonya helped us find our perfect home!

We have worked with Tonya a few times b4. she is awesome. very professional. great on keeping you informed through the entire process. . would recommend her to anyone . She’s fabulous .

I would like to state about Mrs Tonya Mcathy, she’s a professional agent equipped with the real state knowledge; she enjoy providing her client with an honest information. She’s thorough and beyond to make sure that I had a successful home buying experience —- I highly recommend Mrs Tony McCarthy to every future new home buyer. Again, I’m so gratful

Tonya was great. Worked hard for us through difficult situations and we ended up exactly where we wanted to be. Has endless energy and patience.

Tonya was just great, anything we asked of her she was able to do with no problem, we found her to be not only a great realtor, but a very warm and caring person, just a joy to work with during a very stressful time. We would definitely use her again. charlie and carol

Tonya was beyond Amazing! She was always available and extremely flexible. She went above and beyond anything I would have expected from a realtor and exceeded any expectations I had if her when we first met. I would recommend her for a realtor to anyone I could not be more happier with the sell of my old house and purchase of my new homes and it’s all thanks to her hard work and dedication. She is a Super Star!

Tonya did an absolutely exceptional job as my wife and I’s realtor. She continually went above and beyond our expectations and blew us away with her helpfulness and knowledge of the market. My wife and I found ourselves in a tough situation where we needed to quickly find a home in the middle of a crazy housing market, and Tonya guided us every step of the way. Although I didn’t know Tonya before our housing search (we found her by happenstance online), we could not imagine anyone else being our realtor. She responded to all of our questions and concerns within minutes and continually put our needs before her own (driving hours to meet us for showings and stopping on the side of the road while out of town to send us a purchase contract). If you have any doubts or worries about finding a realtor in or anywhere around the Indy area, look no further! Tonya is awesome.

Tonya was extremely helpful throughout the entire process! She went above and beyond to help us sell our home. She is very professional, trustworthy, and definitely willing to help out her clients in any way possible. She is a joy to be around and gets the job done!

Tonya is a breath of fresh air when you need it most! I was referred to Tonya by chance and now I have a sold house (that sold in one day and over asking!) and a new friend! Tonya knows her stuff and she will make sure you’re taken care of. I wish I could give her more stars!

Tonya did a great job assisting us through our first home sale. She answered our questions and kept us well up to date throughout the process.

Tonya was by far the best realtor I have had the pleasure to work with. She never gave up on me, when I was uncertain, or even angry, she was a positive voice in my head, reassuring me that everything would work out. And just like that it did. Mrs. McCarthy made the process easy, she was always their for us, anytime we wanted to see a property she was there. I would and have already recommended her to my family and friends.
Thank you so very much Mrs. McCarty.

Tonya was sweet and knowledgeable. The sale or our house went as smooth as possible. The buying process was not smooth for us and Tonya stepped up to take care of the obstacles not in our control.

Tonya was very helpful, compassionate, organized, and efficient. She has been our realtor through two homes and has been awesome every time.

Tonya is a dedicated and hardworking realtor with excellent communication and interpersonal skills. I chose Tonya as my realtor and entrusted my home buying assignment to her a day prior to her scheduled vacation. I was impressed that while Tonya was on vacation, she maintained constant communication with home sellers and ensured that I viewed listed homes until she returned. Tonya worked with me and guided me throughout the home buying process and ensured that I got the home that I deserved. She possesses the appropriate skills and knowledge required to help clients who intend to buy or sell homes in a competitive real estate market. I strongly recommend Tonya to anyone who intends to buy or sell a home in the real estate market.

Tonya did such a great job throughout the entire process of selling my home. She was exactly what you are hoping for from a realtor. I have already recommended her to as many of my friends and family as I can!

Tonya is fantastic she is the best agent I have ever done business she has become a member of our family I strongly recommend her for your services.

Tonya was great to work with! I highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell their home.

Choosing Tonya was the best decision we made in selling our house! We interviewed 6 different agents and Tonya was the best by far. She was professional and brilliant but also kind and funny. We were instantly impressed by her. But most importantly, she was by far the most knowledgeable, the most thorough and the most dedicated agent. She came well prepared with reports and comps and gathered every tiny detail about the home and our expectations for the sale. She even asked important questions other agents never even mentioned and offered us tons of excellent advice. It was obvious she is very dedicated and great at her job. She was always there to answer our questions or walk us through processes and she even went out of her way to help us with anything we needed like staging and cleaning. She went to bat for us many times with the buyers and their agents. She knows all there is to know about the real-estate business and constantly kept us in the loop. We've said it many times throughout the sell of our home...that choosing Tonya was the best decision. We loved her as our agent and now consider her our dear friend. If you are looking for an agent who can handle anything that comes with the hassle of buying or selling a home and always have your back... Tonya is the agent for you.

Tonya made the home buying + selling process incredibly easy! She was always so responsive and her knowledge of the industry allowed her to answer all our questions on the spot. We were on a tight timeline which didn't phase Tonya one bit. She kept us on track through the entire process and even made it fun!

I met Tonya when she helped me find a home for my mom who was relocating to Indiana from Alabama. She was a joy to work with then and when it came time to sell our house and find our forever home we knew we wanted to work with her again. Tonya was there for us every step of the way. From advice and referrals as we prepared to list to the VERY QUICK sale of our home. She patiently took us through listing after listing until we found or forever home and advocated for us through the purchase. We are so grateful for Tonya!

Tonya was nothing short of amazing for us! This was our first time buying a home and we had no idea what to expect, but Tonya helped us transition smoothly through every step of the process. We could not have done it without her, she took the weight and worry off our shoulders and helped us find the perfect home!

Tonya represented me when I sold my first home in 2017 and most recently she represented me in the purchase of my condo that I’m now residing in.
Tonya is a committed and very dedicated realtor that works very hard to make sure her clients are well taken care of. I would not hesitate to recommend her to Anyone looking to sell our purchase a home.

We have worked with Tonya more than once which is why we decided to have her help find us yet another house! She’s probably the MOST sweetest and attentive person/friend/realitor anyone could ask for. She listened to the things we wanted when it came to location what we wanted in a house and the needs we needed for our house. Would definitely have her be our realtor all over again if ever need be!! We love her❣️