Search Our Agents & Offices

Let us help you find an agent or office near you.

Headshot of Justina Benetis

Justina Benetis

Agent
License Number: 2671242

Inspired by lifestyle, design, and connection, Justina brings a modern, intuitive approach to real estate rooted in helping people find homes where they can truly thrive.

Her background in design, social media, and hospitality gives her a creative eye and a natural people-first approach to her work. She blends aesthetics and storytelling to help clients see how a space can feel and function in their everyday life, guiding them toward homes that align with their lifestyle, vision, and long-term goals.

Raised in Monmouth County, Justina has a deep connection to the area’s natural beauty and lifestyle, from the ocean and wooded landscapes to the charm of its small towns and strong sense of community. After attending Flagler College and spending time exploring new places, she returned home with a renewed appreciation for the environment she grew up in and a desire to help others experience it for themselves.

She is committed to helping clients navigate the buying and selling process with clarity, confidence, and care. Whether working with first-time buyers, young professionals, or those looking for a home that better reflects their lifestyle, Justina focuses on making each step feel grounded, informed, and supported.

Known for her optimism, strong attention to detail, and thoughtful communication style, she strives to make what can often feel overwhelming feel simple and approachable. Her approach is centered on truly understanding her clients and guiding them toward decisions that feel right for them.

Drawn to NextHome Peninsula Realty Group’s collaborative culture and “Humans Over Houses” philosophy, Justina joined the brokerage to be part of a modern, relationship-driven approach to real estate in Monmouth County. She values the emphasis on support, creativity, and community-focused growth, and is excited to continue building her career within a team that aligns with her values.

Justina is committed to helping clients not just find a house, but discover a place where they can truly feel at home.

To explore local living and follow along on her journey, connect with Justina on Instagram @justinabenetis — your local guide to homes, lifestyle, and community.

Coverage

Atlantic Highlands, Colts Neck, Fair Haven, Highlands, Holmdel, Howell, Lincroft, Little Silver, Long Branch, Mantoloking, Middletown, Monmouth Beach, Red Bank, Rumson, Sea Bright, Sea Girt, Shrewsbury, Spring Lake, spring lake heights and Wall

More about Justina...

Luke
What inspired you to get into real estate?
My passion for helping people and appreciation for home, design, and community!
Justina Benetis
Luke
Who is your hero?
My mom, Lina, who immigrated from Lithuania alone and built a beautiful life through resilience.
Justina Benetis
Luke
What do you like to do when you’re not selling real estate?
Be outdoors, go hiking, traveling, exploring new coffee shops and breweries...
Justina Benetis
Luke
Where did you attend college?
Flagler College
Justina Benetis

Recommendations

May 15, 2026 at 10:24 PM

Karly Kornblatt recommends Justina Benetis

Justina is a highly approachable, down-to-earth individual. She takes a proactive approach with her work and is always ready to lend a helping hand. Her strong attention to detail and design allows her to aim for excellence. Her communication is extremely reliable and consistent whether it be answering a question, planning, or simply engaging in friendly banter. Justina's positive attitude is palpable, and anyone who has the opportunity to work with her should take it!
May 13, 2026 at 4:29 PM

Alyssa Castera recommends Justina Benetis

Working with Justina has been such a pleasure & overall a great experience! She is super genuine, hardworking, and easygoing. & She always makes everyone around her feel comfortable and supported. She’s extremely professional, reliable, and truly cares about helping people in any way she can. Anyone looking to work with someone who is trustworthy, personable, and dedicated would be lucky to have her by their side!
May 12, 2026 at 6:07 AM

Jennifer Teeter recommends Justina Benetis

Justina and I have worked together for the past year and a half. She was by far one of the best coworkers I have had the pleasure to work with. She has always been extremely attentive and hard working. Not only is her work ethic excellent, her personality is wonderful. She is always smiling and brings a positive vibe to any space she is in. I have no doubt that she will make an excellent realtor and anyone who works with her is lucky to be around a gem of a person like Justina.
May 11, 2026 at 1:58 PM

Maria Klimik recommends Justina Benetis

Justina is someone you can count on to get the job done, and no matter what it is, at high quality. She brings a level of care and professionalism to everything she touches that is rare to find. The quality of her work is outstanding, whether it's real estate or anything else, she consistently delivers results that exceed expectations. She's personable, easy to communicate with, and dependable. You can tell right away that she's passionate about what she does and genuinely invested in the people she works with. I'd recommend her without hesitation to anyone looking for someone who is both talented and truly dependable.
May 7, 2026 at 7:48 PM

Neringa Liepaite recommends Justina Benetis

Justina has always been such a pleasure—from her sophistication and ability to communicate, to the warmth and passion she brings forth to everything she does. Her dedication and work ethic are rooted in integrity and it’s clear she cares about the long term happiness of her clients. She is reliable, trustworthy, and above all, committed to her mission and outlined goals. Justina is an incredible person to work with and her talents are truly impressive.
May 7, 2026 at 5:38 PM

Charles Penszynski recommends Justina Benetis

Justina is truly a pleasure to work with. She showcases true professionalism from start to finish. I could not recommend her talents enough.

She is goal-oriented, driven, and most important... reliable. Whether in or out of real estate, she truly is a joy to collaborate with and will always ensure that we get to the finish line!
May 7, 2026 at 3:47 PM

Destiny Blair-Twitchell recommends Justina Benetis

Justina is extremely organized and on top of everything she does, she communicates clearly, follows through, and makes things feel a lot less stressful. She’s professional, dependable, and really good at keeping things moving smoothly without making you feel overwhelmed.

You can tell she genuinely cares about doing things well and making sure people feel taken care of throughout the process.
May 7, 2026 at 12:58 PM

Will Gavin recommends Justina Benetis

I would highly recommend Justina. She has an amazing, down to earth personality and always puts in a high level of effort in everything she does. She’s easy to talk to, reliable, and genuinely cares about helping people however she can. Anyone who works with her will quickly see how dedicated, professional, and kind she is. She’s the type of person you feel comfortable trusting and working with from the start.
May 7, 2026 at 12:42 PM

Roberta Zimnickaite recommends Justina Benetis

It’s always a pleasure to work with Justina. She’s incredibly genuine, down to earth, and goes the extra mile for her clients and the people that work beside her. She has an impeccable eye and taste. Super professional, even outside of real estate. She has done some exceptional work and I’m glad to have found her!

Contact Agent

We use cookies to improve your experience.

By continuing to visit this website, you accept our use of cookies. Read our policy here.